To get a second opinion, choose a doctor in the same specialty who is outside your first doctor’s practice, check with your health plan whether you need a referral and what it will pay, and have your records, test results and images sent ahead so the second doctor can review the whole case. Asking for one is your right, about any diagnosis or treatment; Medicare covers one before non-emergency surgery, and Medicaid managed care plans and some states’ HMO laws require plans to provide one.7145
This guide is about the United States and the federal rules; state law can add to them. It is general information, not legal or medical advice, and it does not tell you which care is right for you. For moving your records, see How to Get Your Medical Records Sent to a New Doctor; if your plan refuses to pay, How to Appeal an Insurance Denial
Why a second look matters
Feeling brushed off is common, and it is rarely about one bad doctor. The system often leaves one clinician, in one visit, with whatever part of your history happens to be in front of them, to make a call that can shape years of treatment. A second opinion is the patient’s one built-in way to have the case looked at again, by someone who starts fresh.
The research says a second look often changes the picture. At Mayo Clinic, researchers compared the diagnosis that came with 286 patients referred from primary care with the final diagnosis after the specialist workup. The two were the same in 12% of cases, the final diagnosis was better defined or refined in 66%, and in 21% it was distinctly different.9 A systematic review of patient-initiated second opinions found that a second opinion typically confirms the original diagnosis or treatment, but that 10% to 62% of second opinions led to a major change in the diagnosis, treatment or prognosis, and that more patients got different advice on treatment than on diagnosis.10
Even a careful review of the same material can change the answer. When Johns Hopkins re-read the surgical pathology of 6,171 cases referred in from other hospitals, 86 diagnoses (1.4%) changed in a way that meant a major change in therapy or prognosis, and the authors recommended reviewing the original slides before any major treatment.11
The stakes are high because diagnostic errors are not rare. A 2024 study estimated about 795,000 serious harms (permanent disability or death) from diagnostic error in the United States each year, with stroke, sepsis, pneumonia, venous thromboembolism and lung cancer accounting for 38.7% of them.12 And confidence is a weak guide: in a study of 118 internists working through case vignettes, they diagnosed 55.3% of the easier cases and 5.8% of the more difficult ones correctly, yet their confidence barely moved, 7.2 against 6.4 out of 10.13 A second opinion is not an accusation. It is the check the system does not run for you.
When to ask for one
You can ask about any aspect of your care, but some moments call for it more than others. California’s second-opinion law gives a useful list of reasons a plan must accept, which works anywhere as a checklist:5
- You question whether a recommended surgery is reasonable or necessary.
- You question a diagnosis or plan of care for a condition that threatens your life, a limb or a bodily function, including a serious chronic condition.
- The picture is unclear or complex, test results conflict, or your doctor cannot diagnose the condition.
- The treatment you are on is not improving your condition within a reasonable time.
- You have tried to follow the plan, or raised serious concerns with your doctor, and still have them.
Medicare suggests considering a second opinion whenever a doctor says you need surgery that is not an emergency, and reminds you that it is up to you to decide when and if you have surgery.2 The National Cancer Institute describes getting one after a cancer diagnosis, before treatment begins, as very common.8
The exception is an emergency. Medicare’s own booklet says not to wait for a second opinion if you need emergency surgery, such as for acute appendicitis, blood clots or aneurysms, or accidental injuries.2
You have the right to ask
The American Medical Association’s Code of Medical Ethics lists the rights physicians should respect. They include the right “to obtain copies or summaries of their medical records” and the right “to obtain a second opinion,” alongside the right to “continuity of care.”7
Many people worry that asking will offend their doctor. The National Cancer Institute says that usually the opposite is true: “Most doctors welcome a second opinion,” and many health insurance companies pay for one or even require one, particularly before surgery. It suggests telling your doctor you are satisfied with your care but want to be sure you know all your options, and involving the doctor, because they will need to make your records available.8
A second opinion also does not mean leaving. Medicare’s booklet says that getting a second or third opinion “doesn’t mean you have to change doctors,” and that if you decide to have surgery, you choose which doctor does it.2
Who pays for a second opinion
What you pay depends on the kind of coverage you have. These are the rules read at the source; for an employer or Marketplace plan not covered by a state rule, the plan’s own documents decide.
| Coverage | What the rule says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Original Medicare (Part B) | Covers a second opinion before medically necessary, non-emergency surgery, and a third if the first two differ; you pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after the $283 deductible (2026). Tests the second doctor orders are covered like other medically necessary services.13 | Medicare.gov |
| Medicare Advantage | You have the right to a second opinion, and the plan helps pay for a third if the first two differ. Some plans pay only with a referral, or only for an in-network doctor.2 | Medicare booklet 02173 |
| Medicaid managed care | The plan provides a second opinion from a network provider, or arranges one outside the network, at no cost to you.4 | 42 CFR 438.206(b)(3) |
| California health care service plans | Must provide or authorize one on request; you pay only the copayment for similar referrals; out of network if no qualified in-network doctor exists; a decision within 72 hours, whenever possible, when your health faces an imminent and serious threat.5 | Cal. Health & Safety Code 1383.15 |
| Florida HMOs | A right to a second opinion when you dispute the need for surgery or have a serious injury or illness, from a listed or a non-contract physician in the area; for a non-contract physician you may owe up to 40%.6 | Fla. Stat. 641.51(5) |
Two details are worth knowing. Medicare doesn’t pay for second opinions on surgeries or procedures that aren’t medically necessary, such as cosmetic surgery.2 And in Florida, an HMO may deny reimbursement if you seek more than three such referrals a year and it judges that to be overuse, and after the second opinion the HMO’s own physician’s judgment still controls what the HMO will cover.6
If you have Medicaid without a managed care plan, Medicare’s booklet says Medicaid might also pay for a second opinion before surgery, and to call your Medicaid office to find out.2
Do you need a referral?
It depends on the type of plan. A referral is a written order from your primary care doctor for you to see a specialist; in many HMOs you need one before you get care from anyone except your primary care doctor, and without it the plan may not pay.14 Point of service plans also require a referral from your primary care doctor to see a specialist.15
A PPO lets you use doctors, hospitals and providers outside its network without a referral, for an additional cost. An EPO covers services only from doctors, specialists or hospitals in its network, except in an emergency.15 With Original Medicare, the booklet asks only that the second doctor accepts Medicare, which you can check on Medicare’s Care Compare or by calling 1-800-MEDICARE.2
So to get a second opinion without a referral, you have three options: a plan type that does not need one, paying for the visit yourself, or asking your primary care doctor for the referral. In California, the treating doctor can make the request to the plan as well as you.5
Choosing the second doctor
Look for a doctor in the same specialty, or a more specialized one, who is not part of the first doctor’s group. California’s law captures what qualified means: a doctor acting within their scope of practice with training and expertise in the particular illness or condition.5 Medicare suggests asking your doctor, or another doctor you trust, for a name, and checking that the doctor accepts Medicare.2 For cancer, the National Cancer Institute’s Cancer Information Service, at 1-800-4-CANCER, can help you find a specialist.8
Some large referral hospitals re-read the original material as a rule rather than relying on the first report: Johns Hopkins does so for surgical pathology from other hospitals.11
Get your records to the second doctor
A second opinion is only as good as the history the second doctor sees. Medicare’s booklet puts it first on the list: ask the first doctor to send your medical records to the second doctor, so that you may not have to repeat tests, then call the second doctor’s office to make sure they have them.2 The National Cancer Institute names test results and x-rays as what the second doctor needs.8
There are two legal routes, and you can use both. First, HIPAA lets a covered entity disclose your health information “for treatment activities of a health care provider,” so the first office may send records to the second doctor without a signed form from you.16 Second, under your right of access, if you direct an office in writing to send a copy straight to another person, it must do so; the request must be signed and must clearly name the person and where to send it.17 The office must act within 30 days, with one 30-day extension if it explains the delay in writing.17 If you ask for an electronic copy of records kept electronically, it must give them to you in the electronic form you ask for if it can readily produce it.17
What to ask for, depending on the question:
- The visit notes and the letter or report with the diagnosis or recommendation you want reviewed.
- Test results, with the dates, and the reports of any imaging.
- The images themselves, not only the reports, if a scan is central to the diagnosis.
- For a diagnosis made on a biopsy, ask whether the second doctor wants the original pathology slides reviewed: re-reading them is where the Johns Hopkins study found its changed diagnoses.11
- Records from other doctors who treated the same problem, and a list of your medicines.
Records scattered across offices are the usual reason a second opinion stalls. If you need records from several places, the request itself is in our guide to getting all your medical records.
Step by step
- Write down the question you want answered: the diagnosis, the treatment, or whether to have the surgery.
- Call your plan, or read its documents: is a second opinion covered, do you need a referral, and must the doctor be in network?2
- Ask your primary care doctor for a referral if the plan needs one, and for names.
- Book the second doctor, and ask the office what records and images it wants before the visit.
- Have the records sent: ask the first office to send them for treatment, or send it a signed written request naming the second doctor and the address.1617
- A few days before, call the second office to confirm the records arrived.2
- At the visit, say what the first doctor recommended and which tests you have had, ask your list of questions, and bring a family member or friend if you can.2
- Ask for the second doctor’s written report, and for a copy to go to your first doctor.
When the two opinions differ
Medicare’s booklet gives two next steps: talk more about your condition with your first doctor, or see a third doctor, which Medicare helps pay for when the first two opinions differ.2 The decision is still yours: you choose whether to have surgery and which doctor does it.2
A written report makes this conversation easier. California requires the second-opinion doctor to give both you and the first doctor a consultation report, including any procedures or tests the second doctor believes appropriate.5 Elsewhere, ask for one: it is part of your record, and you have a right to a copy.17
If your plan says no
A refusal can usually be challenged. In California, a plan that denies a second opinion must tell you in writing why and tell you of your right to file a grievance.5 In Florida, a subscriber denied reimbursement under the second-opinion rule has recourse to the HMO’s grievance procedures.6 For other plans, use the plan’s appeal process; the steps and deadlines are in our guide to appealing an insurance denial. A patient advocate can help with the calls and the paperwork.
Every one of these routes asks for the same thing: your records. An appeal, a grievance and the second doctor’s review all start from the history on paper, which is why gathering it first saves the most time.
Frequently asked questions
Can I get a second opinion without a referral?
Yes, with a PPO, which lets you see doctors outside the network without a referral for an additional cost, or if you pay yourself. Many HMOs and point of service plans require a referral from your primary care doctor first.1514
Does Medicare pay for a second opinion?
Yes, Part B covers a second opinion before medically necessary, non-emergency surgery, and a third if the first two differ. You pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after the deductible.1
Will my doctor be offended if I ask for a second opinion?
Usually not. The National Cancer Institute says most doctors welcome a second opinion, and getting one is a patient right in the AMA’s Code of Medical Ethics.87
How do I get my records to the second doctor?
Ask the first office to send them; it may do so for treatment without your signed form. Or send it a signed written request naming the second doctor, which it must act on within 30 days.1617
How anyhealth helps
A second opinion is one of the strongest ways to push back when you have been brushed off, and it depends on the second doctor seeing your whole history. anyhealth finds every provider and insurer you have used and collects all your records for you, across portals, email and fax, so the second doctor has the full picture before you walk in.
References
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Second surgical opinions. Medicare.gov.
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Getting a Second Opinion Before Surgery. CMS Product No. 02173, revised December 2021.
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare costs. Medicare.gov, what you pay in 2026.
- 42 CFR 438.206, Availability of services. Medicaid managed care, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, text as of November 9, 2026.
- California Health and Safety Code 1383.15. California Legislative Information; amended by Stats. 2001, Ch. 328.
- Florida Statutes 641.51, Quality assurance program; second medical opinion requirement. Online Sunshine, the Florida Legislature.
- American Medical Association. Code of Medical Ethics Opinion 1.1.3: Patient Rights.
- National Cancer Institute. Finding Health Care Services. Getting a second opinion after a cancer diagnosis.
- Van Such M, Lohr R, Beckman T, Naessens JM. Extent of diagnostic agreement among medical referrals. J Eval Clin Pract. 2017;23(4):870-874.
- Payne VL, Singh H, Meyer AN, Levy L, Harrison D, Graber ML. Patient-initiated second opinions: systematic review of characteristics and impact on diagnosis, treatment, and satisfaction. Mayo Clin Proc. 2014;89(5):687-696.
- Kronz JD, Westra WH, Epstein JI. Mandatory second opinion surgical pathology at a large referral hospital. Cancer. 1999;86(11):2426-2435.
- Newman-Toker DE, Nassery N, Schaffer AC, et al. Burden of serious harms from diagnostic error in the USA. BMJ Qual Saf. 2024;33(2):109-120.
- Meyer AN, Payne VL, Meeks DW, Rao R, Singh H. Physicians’ diagnostic accuracy, confidence, and resource requests: a vignette study. JAMA Intern Med. 2013;173(21):1952-1958.
- HealthCare.gov. Referral. Glossary.
- HealthCare.gov. Health insurance plan & network types: HMOs, PPOs, and more.
- 45 CFR 164.506, Uses and disclosures to carry out treatment, payment, or health care operations. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations.
- 45 CFR 164.524, Access of individuals to protected health information. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, text as of November 9, 2026.